How to Recover from a Google Algorithm Penalty

Seeing a sudden drop in your website traffic can be heart-wrenching for any Brisbane business owner. Whether it’s a manual action or an algorithmic shift, a Google penalty can feel like your digital shopfront has been hidden behind a brick wall, but with a systematic approach, you can recover your rankings and come back stronger.

Why This Matters

---

Prerequisites: What You’ll Need

• Google Search Console (GSC): Verified access to your website property.
• Google Analytics: To compare traffic dates with known algorithm updates.
• An SEO Audit Tool: (e.g., SEMrush, Ahrefs, or a free crawler like Screaming Frog).
• Your ABN & Business Details: To verify your identity if filing a reconsideration request.
• Patience: Recovery can take anywhere from a few weeks to several months.

---

Step 1: Distinguish Between a Manual Action and an Algorithmic Update

First, you need to know what you are fighting.

• Manual Action: This is when a human reviewer at Google has determined your site doesn’t comply with their webmaster guidelines.
• Algorithmic Update: This is an automated change to Google’s ranking system (like a Core Update or a Spam Update) that has negatively impacted your site.

Step 2: Pinpoint the Exact Date of the Drop

Go to your Google Analytics (GA4) or the 'Performance' report in GSC. Identify the exact day your traffic began to slide.

Compare this date against a reliable Google Algorithm Update tracker (like MozCast or Semrush Sensor). Australian businesses often see the effects of updates a day or two after they roll out in the US. If your traffic drop aligns perfectly with a "Core Update," you know exactly what the culprit is.

Step 3: Check for "Thin" or Low-Quality Content

Google’s recent updates, particularly the 'Helpful Content' updates, target sites that provide little value.

Step 4: Audit Your Backlink Profile

If you have a manual action for "Unnatural Links," you need to identify spammy sites linking to you.

Use a tool like Ahrefs or the 'Links' report in GSC. Look for patterns of "toxic" links:

• Links from "Link Farms" or directories that look like they haven't been updated since 2005.
• Over-optimised anchor text (e.g., 500 links all using the exact phrase "Best Plumber Brisbane").
• Links from irrelevant foreign language sites (e.g., a Russian gambling site linking to your local bakery).

Step 5: Clean Up On-Page Over-Optimisation

Sometimes we try too hard. If you have stuffed your keywords into every heading, image alt-text, and footer link, Google might flag this as "Keyword Stuffing."

Step 6: Address User Experience (Core Web Vitals)

A site that is slow or broken on mobile will eventually be penalised in the rankings.

Check the 'Experience' section in GSC. Look for "LCP" (Largest Contentful Paint) or "CLS" (Cumulative Layout Shift) issues. If your site takes longer than 3 seconds to load on a standard Telstra mobile connection, you have work to do.

Step 7: Fix Technical Errors and Redirects

Ensure your site isn't suffering from "Zombie Pages." These are old, broken, or 404-error pages that waste Google's crawling budget.

• Redirect old service pages to relevant new ones using 301 redirects.
• Ensure your SSL certificate (the padlock icon) is valid and active.

Step 8: Remove or 'Noindex' Low-Value Pages

You don't have to delete everything. For pages that are necessary for your business (like 'Terms and Conditions') but don't need to rank, add a "noindex" tag. This tells Google: "Keep this page on my site, but don't bother showing it in search results."

Step 9: Improve E-E-A-T (Experience, Expertise, Authoritativeness, Trustworthiness)

For Australian businesses, trust is everything.

• Ensure your ABN is visible in the footer.
• Create a detailed 'About Us' page featuring real staff photos.
• Link to your professional memberships (e.g., Master Builders Queensland).
• Make sure your contact details (Phone, Email, Brisbane Address) match your Google Business Profile exactly.

Step 10: Submit a Reconsideration Request (Manual Actions Only)

If you had a Manual Action and you have fixed the issues, you must ask Google to clear it.

Step 11: Monitor and Pivot

After making changes, monitor your GSC data weekly. Recovery isn't a vertical line; it's usually a slow curve. If you don't see movement after a month, you may need to look deeper into your site's technical architecture.

---

Common Mistakes to Avoid

• The "Nuke" Option: Don't delete your whole website and start again on a new domain unless absolutely necessary. You'll lose all the positive history you've built.
• Ignoring the Mobile View: Most Brisbane users search on mobile. If your site looks great on your office iMac but breaks on an iPhone, you won't recover.
• Buying "Recovery Services": Be wary of anyone promising an "instant fix" for a penalty. Recovery is a manual, merit-based process.

Troubleshooting

• "I fixed everything but traffic is still flat": Google needs to re-crawl your site. Use the 'URL Inspection' tool in GSC to "Request Indexing" on your most important pages to speed things up.
• "I got a second Manual Action": This usually happens if you didn't fix the root cause. Go back to Step 4 and be more aggressive with your cleanup.

Next Steps

If you’re feeling overwhelmed or the technical jargon is a bit much, our team at Local Marketing Group can help diagnose your site and build a recovery roadmap. Visit us at https://lmgroup.au/contact to start the conversation.