The Industry's Dirty Secret About Page Speed
I’m going to start with a statement that makes most SEO 'gurus' twitch: Your 100/100 Google PageSpeed Insights score is probably a waste of time.
There, I said it. At Local Marketing Group, we’ve seen countless Brisbane business owners pour thousands of dollars into developers chasing a green circle, only to find their conversion rates haven't budged an inch. Last year, a client in Newstead came to us after spending $5k on 'speed optimisation' with another agency. Their site was lightning fast according to the lab tests, but it was still losing 40% of mobile traffic before the page even finished rendering on a standard 4G connection in the CBD.
Why? Because the industry has spent a decade obsessing over synthetic benchmarks instead of human experience.
In 2026, page speed isn't about a number. It’s about the psychological friction between a user’s intent and your website’s response. If you’re still following the 2018 playbook of 'optimise your images and minify your CSS,' you’re missing 90% of the battle.
In this deep dive, we’re going to compare the three dominant approaches to speed: The 'Checklist' Approach, The 'Platform' Approach, and the 'Experience-First' Approach. One of these will actually make you money; the others are just expensive hobbies.
---
1. The 'Checklist' Approach: Why Best Practices Often Fail
This is what 95% of agencies do. They run a report, see a list of warnings, and start ticking boxes. - "Optimise images? Check." - "Minify JavaScript? Check." - "Enable Gzip? Check."
Here’s the problem: This approach treats every byte as equal. It’s a linear solution to a non-linear problem. I’ve seen sites that pass every 'best practice' check but still feel sluggish because the order of operations is wrong.
The 'Render-Blocking' Myth
Most developers will tell you to move all your scripts to the footer to avoid render-blocking. Sounds logical, right? But if your critical 'Call to Action' button depends on a JavaScript library to function, you’ve just created a 'ghost' button. The user sees it, clicks it, and nothing happens for three seconds.That’s a worse user experience than a slightly slower-loading page. You’ve broken the trust of the user. We see this constantly on sites where owners think website design matters most, leading them to load heavy animations that look great but kill the 'Time to Interactive'.
The Australian Reality: The 'NBN Gap'
While Google’s testing servers are often sitting in high-speed data centres in the US or Singapore, your customer is likely sitting on a patchy 5G connection on the train to Milton or dealing with a mediocre NBN connection in the suburbs. The 'Checklist' approach rarely accounts for high latency. If your site requires 50 separate requests to render—even if those files are small—the latency of each request will kill your speed in the real world.---
2. The 'Platform' Approach: Can You Buy Your Way to Speed?
This approach suggests that the tech stack itself is the solution. "Switch to Shopify!" or "Move to Webflow!"
There is some merit here. We’ve written extensively about how to stop choosing platforms based on hype, and the platform you choose sets your 'speed ceiling'.
WordPress: The High-Maintenance Race Car
WordPress can be the fastest platform on earth, or it can be a bloated mess. Most Brisbane SMEs are running 'Franken-sites'—WordPress installs with 35 active plugins, a heavy page builder like Elementor, and a $20/month shared hosting plan.If you are on WordPress, speed isn't about a plugin like WP Rocket. It’s about architecture. - The Good: Complete control over every line of code. - The Bad: You have enough rope to hang yourself. One poorly coded plugin can add 2 seconds to your TTFB (Time to First Byte).
SaaS (Shopify/Webflow): The Speed Governor
SaaS platforms provide a high 'floor'. You can’t really mess up the server configuration. However, you also have a 'ceiling'. You can't control the underlying infrastructure. If Shopify’s global CDN has a hiccup, your site slows down, and there’s nothing you can do about it.My Take: Don't switch platforms solely for speed. It’s a $10,000 solution to a $1,000 problem. Fix your execution first.
---
3. The 'Experience-First' Approach: The Only One That Matters
In 2026, Google’s Core Web Vitals (CWV) have evolved. They no longer just care if a page is fast; they care if it feels stable and responsive. This is where we focus at Local Marketing Group.
LCP (Largest Contentful Paint) is a Branding Metric
LCP measures when the largest element on the screen (usually your hero image or headline) becomes visible. This is where the 'ego' problem crops up. We often tell clients to stop designing for their ego because that massive, 4K video background of your office in Fortitude Valley is destroying your LCP.Actionable Insight: Use 'Priority Hints'. You can literally tell the browser: "Hey, this specific image is the most important thing on the page, download it before anything else." It’s a one-line code change that can shave 1.5 seconds off your perceived load time.
CLS (Cumulative Layout Shift): The Silent Killer
Have you ever been on a site, gone to click a link, and suddenly the page jumps and you click an ad instead? That’s CLS. It’s infuriating.In the QLD trade services industry—think plumbers or electricians—we see this a lot with 'Book Now' banners that pop in late. The user goes to call, the page shifts, and they end up clicking a generic 'About Us' link. They get frustrated and leave.
The Fix: Reserve space for your elements. If you know an image is 400x300 pixels, tell the browser that in the CSS. Don't let the browser 'guess' and then adjust once the image arrives.
INP (Interaction to Next Paint): The New King
As of 2024/2025, INP replaced First Input Delay. It measures the delay of every interaction a user has with the page. This is where heavy tracking scripts (looking at you, HubSpot and Hotjar) kill your conversions.If a user clicks your mobile menu and it takes 300ms to open, they will click it again. Now they’ve queued two actions, the menu opens and shuts instantly, and the user thinks your site is broken.
---
The 'Bloat' Comparison: A Real-World Scenario
Let’s look at two hypothetical Brisbane dental clinics.
Clinic A (The Checklist Approach): - Scores 98/100 on Mobile. - Uses a 'headless' build that cost $20k. - Has zero tracking scripts to keep speed up. - Result: Fast, but they have no idea where their leads come from, and the site feels 'sterile'.
Clinic B (The Experience-First Approach): - Scores 72/100 on Mobile (The 'Orange' zone). - Uses smart loading for their booking widget. - Uses a high-quality, compressed hero image that connects with patients. - Uses 'Partytown' to move tracking scripts to a web worker (off the main thread). - Result: The site feels instant to a human, they track every lead, and their conversion rate is 3x higher than Clinic A.
Which one would you rather own?
---
5 Non-Negotiable Speed Tactics for 2026
If you want to actually improve your bottom line, stop reading generic 'speed tips' and execute these five things:
1. The 'Third-Party' Audit
Open your Chrome DevTools, go to the 'Network' tab, and filter by 'Third Party'. If you see 15 different domains (Facebook, Google, LinkedIn, TikTok, Hotjar, Chatbots), you have a problem.The Rule: If a script isn't actively making you money this month, delete it. Most businesses have 'ghost' pixels from agencies they fired three years ago still running on their site.
2. Modern Image Formats (AVIF, not WebP)
WebP is old news. AVIF offers 30-50% better compression than WebP with higher quality. If your developer isn't using AVIF in 2026, they are lazy. Most modern browsers (and iPhones) support it perfectly now.3. Local Font Hosting
Stop pulling fonts from Google Fonts. It requires an extra DNS lookup and a connection to a different server. Download the font files, put them on your own server, and usefont-display: swap;. This ensures the user sees text immediately in a system font, which then 'swaps' to your brand font once loaded. No more blank screens.
4. Speculative Loading
This is the 'magic' trick. Use a library likequicklink or instant.page. When a user hovers over a link (like your 'Pricing' page), the browser starts downloading that page in the background. By the time the user actually clicks, the page is already in their cache. It loads in 0ms.
5. Edge Functions
If you’re a local Brisbane business, your site should be served from a server in Sydney or Brisbane, not California. Use a provider like Cloudflare with 'Early Hints' enabled. This allows the server to tell the browser which files it will need before the HTML is even fully generated.---
Stop Chasing Ghosts
I’ve spent 15 years in digital marketing, and I’ve never seen a business fail because their PageSpeed score was 85 instead of 95. I have seen businesses fail because their site was so 'optimised' for bots that it became unusable for humans.
Speed is a functional requirement, not a marketing strategy. It’s the foundation, not the house. If your foundation is cracked (i.e., your site takes 10 seconds to load), fix it immediately. But once your site loads in under 2.5 seconds on a 4G connection, stop. Move on to your messaging, your offer, and your sales funnel.
If your current agency is sending you monthly reports obsessing over 'Total Blocking Time' but can't tell you why your 'Contact Us' page isn't converting, they are hiding behind metrics that don't matter.
Summary of Actionable Steps
1. Test on a real device: Grab a three-year-old Android phone, go to a coffee shop with bad Wi-Fi, and try to use your site. That is your real speed. 2. Audit your scripts: Kill any tracking pixel that isn't providing actionable data. 3. Prioritise the 'Fold': Make sure the first thing a user sees is usable within 1.5 seconds. 4. Check your hosting: If you're paying less than $50/month for hosting, you're likely on a congested server. Upgrade to a VPS or managed hosting with local Australian nodes.At the end of the day, speed is about respect. Respecting your visitor's time. If you do that, Google will reward you, but more importantly, your customers will too.
Think your site might be slower than it looks? Let’s cut through the fluff. Contact Local Marketing Group for a real-world performance audit that focuses on conversions, not just circles.